All Saints Church rises above Orton on a low hill, its whitewashed tower a familiar landmark for Coast to Coast walkers entering the village. Much of the tower dates from the 16th century and holds a peal of eight bells, though earlier elements of the church reach back to the 12th century. Within, the red sandstone font bears the date 1662, and the baptistry features stained glass by Beatrice Whistler, linking this modest Lakeland church to one of America’s most celebrated artists.

The earliest church at Orton was likely a modest and simple structure, reflecting the small rural settlement it served. By the 13th century, a more permanent stone building had replaced it, laid out in a classic cruciform plan with chancel, nave, crossing and north and south transepts. This medieval form established the basic footprint that later generations would enlarge and adapt.

The churchyard occupies a gentle rise within the village of Orton, with open views across the surrounding limestone countryside. In the far distance, the higher ground of Orton Scar can be seen rising beyond the village. Many gravestones bear timeworn carvings and symbols, some dating back more than two centuries, and grazing sheep are often seen quietly maintaining the grass among them.